Ho mangiato alle otto.
I ate at eight.
One finished event at a known moment.
English / Italiano
English “I ate” can use either Italian past tense. Use the passato prossimo for a completed event, and the imperfetto for an ongoing situation, habit, or description in the past. The timelines below show the difference.
passato prossimo: a finished event, drawn as a dot or a closed barimperfetto: ongoing or repeated, drawn as an open band
Ho mangiato alle otto.
I ate at eight.
One finished event at a known moment.
Mangiavo quando Carlo ha telefonato.
I was eating when Carlo called.
The imperfetto describes what was in progress. The passato prossimo gives the event that happened during it.
Da bambino mangiavo molta pasta.
As a child I used to eat a lot of pasta.
A habit, repeated an uncounted number of times.
Faceva freddo e pioveva.
It was cold and it was raining.
Description: weather, feelings, how things were. The start and end are not stated.
Ho vissuto a Roma per due anni.
I lived in Rome for two years.
A period with a stated length is treated as a completed event, so it takes the passato prossimo.
Vivevo a Roma.
I was living in Rome. I used to live in Rome.
The same verb with no length stated. It describes a situation in the past, often as background to another event.
a counted or dated event
a scene, a habit, a state
These words are hints, not rules. English gives a hint too: “was eating” and “used to eat” normally correspond to the imperfetto, while plain “ate” can be either.
With sapere and conoscere the tense changes the natural English translation. With volere, potere and dovere the passato prossimo often implies that the action really happened, but that reading depends on context.
| Verb | Imperfetto | Imperfetto in English | Passato prossimo | Passato prossimo in English | How firm |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| sapere | sapevo | I knew | ho saputo | I found out, I learned | clear shift |
| conoscere | conoscevo | I knew (a person) | ho conosciuto | I met, I got to know | clear shift |
| volere | volevo | I wanted to | ho voluto | I wanted to (often: and did) | tendency |
| potere | potevo | I could, I was able to | ho potuto | I was able to (often: and did) | tendency |
| dovere | dovevo | I had to, I was supposed to | ho dovuto | I had to (often: and did) | tendency |
The imperfetto is almost entirely regular. Take off -re and add -vo, -vi, -va, -vamo, -vate, -vano.
| Person | parlare | prendere | dormire | essere |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| io | parlavo | prendevo | dormivo | ero |
| tu | parlavi | prendevi | dormivi | eri |
| lui / lei | parlava | prendeva | dormiva | era |
| noi | parlavamo | prendevamo | dormivamo | eravamo |
| voi | parlavate | prendevate | dormivate | eravate |
| loro | parlavano | prendevano | dormivano | erano |
Essere is the main irregular verb. Fare, dire and bere use a longer stem: facevo, dicevo, bevevo.